TOL
I have always thought my investments in TOL had been disappointments. Why? Because I sold them off at a very handsome profit but the share price has never recovered to more than AUD$20 each.
Subsequently, I was handed TOL shares via the takeover of PRK (Patrick Corp). I thought it has been miserable but in fact, I forgot that PRK tripled its shares (1 share became 3 shares in 2004). Hence, I should not take $14.77 per share but 1/3rd of that, ie. $4.93 each. When TOL took it over, it also gave $3 cash per PRK share plus 0.4 TOL share. Hence the real price was only $1.93 and today, Japan Post lobbed a takeover bid for TOL at $9.04. So on top of dividends, I have made more than 4 times the investment in PRK.
I did think about buying more TOL shares recently purely for its yield but the parcel is held not in my super fund so the franked dividends are not as appealing.